Director Barry Levinson has always captured the dynamics of fulfilling matters. The Alto Knights is a true story that keepsfalling stale. With a 20th century setting, the film builds on the fundamentals of cinematics to tell a story of politics, criminality and connection. Much of this movie relies on the performance of Robert De Niro who plays both Vito Genovese and Frank Costello.

The richness of The Alto Knights is in its approach using noir-type writing. Like many other mob flicks, the character development does not sync up with the foundation in The Alto Knights. The only lines that seem straight are in theperformances of De Niro’s characters going up against each other.  Over the years, De Niro has always displayed a loyal attitude with his serious words. Those elements are utilized again, but the continuity is flawed in The Alto Knights.

The plot focuses on both Vito and Frank and their background as crime family rivals. With their various connections and contacts, discrepancies brew below the surface in The Alto Knights. The wife of Frank Costello is Bobbie Costello (played by Debra Messing). Family integrity is presented as critical in a captivating way in The Alto Knights. There are many conflicts and disagreements between Vito and Frank, many related to the mob and previous events. Some issues end of in the courts where more secrets are revealed.

There is no clear line of resolution in The Alto Knights even though there is an attempt to paint a portrait of good and bad. Since both Vito and Frank are criminals, the apple does not fall far from the tree. The dynamics of the story weave frustrating emotions through the film’s central theme which tries hard to fly high. Levinson’s direction does what it can to aid understanding. The execution, however, is mediocre.

The uncharted territory surrounding the mob seems too vast to build an effective storyline. Vito and Frank both look like emperors of the mob. Deep down, the story is about relationships and trust becoming the bigger problem, yet the lines are unclear in The Alto Knights. Unfortunately, the theme of a family sticking together does not sell like it used to. Levinson’s direction this time around lacks to a massive level in The Alto Knights.

On a positive note, the biographical side of the story compelling, especially when related to the evolving era of mobsters and drug dealers. The deep examination of “who one knows” does not reveal any truth but simply adds to a stirring pot that keeps trying to find the pieces. De Niro’s performance is entertaining, yet not amazing because of the script.

Truly, this is one of the most disappointing films by Levinson. I rarely throw movies under the bus and instead try to find the best in all films. This is only the second time that Levinson has directed a mafia flick. His last one was Bugsy back in 1992 and now three decades later, the writing simply got stale when it came time for this film. Deep down, The Alto Knights has a stellar foundation of separating groups from gangs, affiliations, and operations. Frankly, building on this foundation is where all bets are off on any form of achievement this time around. The only real achievement in this movie is seen through the eyes of De Niro. One and a half out of four stars.