
A long title and too many mentions of the name Nick…with mediocrity. A clever premise is attempted, but it is dry from the start. Written and directed by BenDavid Grabinski, the title itself has the characters in order. However, their dynamic feels like the writing was being done just as the filming was completed. I only say this, because so many moments seem like the characters are trying to establish themselves. The conflicts go on, and the film continues to jump back and forth in a blur. With just enough chemistry, the film still drags. Vince Vaughn plays Future Nick/Present Nick, James Marsden plays Quick Draw Mike, and Eiza Gonzalez plays Alice. The setup is an underworld of criminality going awry, and much of that is out of place.
The plot of the film is trying to find a rat—someone who has uncovered information, putting a criminal in jail. The two main criminals are Sosa (Keith David) and Jimmy Boy (Jimmy Tatro). Mike, Nick, Nick, and Alice are also gangsters; however, they fly below the radar. The utilization of the other Nick and a time machine presents a conflict from within. Other than that, the film goes back and forth with trying to figure out who is responsible for causing an interruption in the organized crime-scene. The puzzle is witty along with the chemistry of Vaughn and Marsden, but the execution keeps missing its hoops to score.
The film is a suspense and a comedy that is entirely misconstrued. The setup keeps flowing back to Vaughn playing two different Nicks. That part is what tested my patience with Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice, primarily because I thought there was going to be more to the mystery aspect. It ended up relating back to trying to find comedy in betrayal while at the same time, the continuity continued to be flawed. Marsden is probably the savior of the film, primarily because his humor and nice guy vibes are what kept on creating some promising elements to the film.
In a fair context, I felt like the film was Collateral meets The Hangover, as it has lots of violence and some gritty moments, but at the same time, it tries to party. Unfortunately, this “party” is a mess. Vaughn playing two versions of himself, a poorly written underworld concept, and too many holes leading to incomplete notions. It was still fun and comedic, but also just out and out poorly done. It does not know when to stop.
Mike &Nick & Nick Alice is not terrible, but it does bring on the boredom. The fun is primarily from the humor of Vaughn and Marsden, but it is not enough to save this film. The characters as the film’s title capture the attention, but then audience enters a door of unknowns. Some may find joy in this espionage type-comedy depending on how open of a mind they have. I for onewas not sold though. I do give it credit for keeping up the quirkiness of having Vaughn as two Nicks. “Two Nicks” leads tothe rating of two out of four stars for Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice.

